Halczenko’s case stems from his refusal to get vaccinated against Covid-19 based on a religious objection to the use of cell lines derived from aborted fetuses in the development or testing of the vaccines.Īscension rejected Halczenko’s request for a religious exemption in October. The dissenting judge in that case called the majority’s opinion an “orgy of jurisprudential violence.” Injunction Denied The “ongoing coercion” against the United workers to get vaccinated despite their faith-based objections qualifies as an “extraordinary and rare” situation calling for interim relief, a divided Fifth Circuit panel said. over its now-defunct policy of putting those who seek religious accommodations for its shot requirement on unpaid leave did get a second chance at winning an injunction thanks to an appellate court ruling in February. The case gives the circuit court a chance to either reinforce or lower the legal barriers that so far have prevented workers from obtaining immediate court orders against private employers that denied their requests for exceptions to Covid-19 vaccine mandates.ĭistrict courts have rejected all the requests for preliminary injunctions that they’ve ruled on in those cases as of May 17, according to a Bloomberg Law analysis. ![]() ![]() But Halczenko contends that Ascension’s decision to turn aside his request for a religious exemption and fire him could end up ruining his career as a pediatric intensive care physician unless the court steps in.Įven if Halczenko convinces the Seventh Circuit that potential career damage merits a preliminary injunction, he’d have to clear several other hurdles to win a court order against Ascension. The judge found that Halczenko failed to show he’d suffer irreparable harm without the court order. The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit May 31 will consider the arguments of Paul Halczenko, who’s contesting a federal district judge’s decision denying his request for a preliminary injunction against Ascension Health Inc. A federal appeals court in Chicago will hear oral arguments in an Indiana doctor’s bid to block a health-care system from requiring that workers get vaccinated against Covid-19 despite religious objections.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |